Music Essay | posted 01.07.2019
Women Of Jazz
We Insist Female
Women in jazz are still not a matter of course. That has to change. For in the past, female musicians have had a decisive influence on jazz and the future is also in their hands.
Text Lars Fleischmann
Soj_women_magazin_artikel_1024px_685px
Rubriken_sticker_detail_02

A frightful hobgoblin stalks throughout jazz. We are haunted dby the ghost of Gender Equality. At the end of 2018, the Union Deutscher Jazzmusiker (UDJ) adopted a »Joint Statement on Equality for Women in Jazz«. Better late than never, one might think. In addition to the demands for a gender-neutral language, for a fair distribution of functions and offices and for a gender-balanced pedagogy, the declaration states that even today there is still a lot of trouble: "The jazz scene in Germany is still decisively influenced by men. According to the Jazz Study 2016, women make up only one fifth of all female jazz musicians in Germany. When looking at the distribution among the various instrument groups, it is also noticeable that only 12% of instrumentalists, but 86% of singers are female«.

Unbelievable conditions that prevail here in Germany, but also in the rest of the world. Institutional unequal treatment leads, for example, to four public broadcasting big bands with a total of two (!) female instrumentalists. That makes about 3% of the ensemble members. So it’s time for a jazz version of the legendary essay by art historian Linda Nochlin, which was published in 1971 under the name »Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?« Here Nochlin examines not the individual obstacles to the rise of female artists, but the institutional ones. The fundamental basis for an investigation of this kind is certainly a list of female musicians who »made it«, who were able to gain national or international attention and significance.

The history of jazz is by no means a solely male-dominated one, even though it was dominated by men. Especially for the early years of jazz, the historical facts are extremely sparse. Only a few names of female artists have been handed down, which is partly due to the fact that many marching bands (from which the first jazz combos were formed) had an “all-male-policy”. Nevertheless, on closer inspection, it quickly becomes clear that there were female actors despite this. A prominent example is certainly Lil Hardin Armstrong, the wife of Louis Armstrong, who played the piano as part of the Hot Five. She is also considered (according to her biographer) to be one of the most important players behind the scenes of New Orleans Jazz.

The history of jazz is by no means a solely male-dominated one, even though it was dominated by men.

Other important female figures from the early days of jazz however have forgotten historiography. Even a Lil Hardin Armstrong is only known to people with deeper insight – despite all the attributed meaning. Only the two singers Ella Fitzgerald and Billie Holiday could become big stars around the year 1935. A closer look is nevertheless worth it. While Blanche Calloway was the bandleader (probably the first) of several swing formations from 1926, the career of Mary Lou Williams began in the same year. Williams can be considered a child prodigy. At the age of three she learned to play the piano, at six she performed for the first time and at 16 she toured with her husband »Bearcat« Williams. But it almost didn’t get that far, because the other members of the Vaudeville group Syncopaters thought it wrong, even injustice, that a woman was playing in the band. _»Music is craft! And Craftsmanship is Male« _. According to the legend, the decisive argument for her employment was her hard, very male keystroke. Until her death in 1981, she not only composed over 300 music pieces (interpreted by all the greats of jazz history), but is also considered the »mother of be-bop«, as she supported many artists in Harlem in the 1940s and 1950s – also financially.

Let’s get back to the two aforementioned Grand Dames, Fitzgerald and Holiday. In 1935, drummer and composer Chick Webb searched for a singer and discovered the 17-year-old Ella Fitzgerald at a talent competition in New York. An incomparable career began, with accolades at all levels. She is regarded as one of the inventors of scat singing and improvised on well-known and existing songs, which turned many of her interpretations into references and still today – from Beyoncé to Fatima – is regarded by many singers as a role model. While Fitzgerald with her youthful and discreet manner could be regarded as a »nerd«, Billie Holiday can be described as a »troublemaker«. Meanwhile one should exercise caution with the term, because her childhood was »not easy«, as it is said, if one does not want to say that she was marked by poverty, rape and prostitution. To put all this behind her, she started singing inspired by Bessie Smith (another such female artist; called: The Empress of Blues). Her idiosyncratic style, which was something very special, not despite, but because of his naive, untrained nature and the untrained voice, quickly helped her to fame. What Billie Holiday lacked in training she made up for with soul, dedication and – you could call it that – the inherent pain of life. She tried to numb this pain all her life with alcohol and heroin, which failed as expected and destroyed the voice and soon led to death in 1959. Meanwhile she influenced not only Janis Joplin, but also Nina Simone. Not only politically active in the civil rights movement, but also recognized as a singer and pianist, Simone is today one of the most famous artists of her time. That was not always the case. It was not until the nineties that she gained her world fame, until then she was considered by many (white) men in the boardrooms to be too idiosyncratic, stubborn and difficult. Early on, Nina Simone orientated herself away from the USA, out into the wide world, to France and also Africa. Here she was celebrated, revered and honored.

This shows the imbalance, that there was no lack of »voices« (means singers, of course), but the instrumentalists are in short supply. On the surface, two known exceptions »of all things« agreed on the same instrument: the harp. Both Dorothy Ashby and Alice Coltrane took care of the classical, European and »white« instrument. This should not astonish, since the traditional jazz instruments (from trumpet to percussion), and thus also positions in bands, were mostly reserved for men. For Alice Coltrane this is only conditionally true; she enjoyed an education at jazz piano and especially her later works (many published under the spiritual name Turyasangitananda) are characterized by organ and e-organ sounds. Dorothy Ashby, on the other hand, had a reliable relationship to the harp and specialized to such an extent that she must still be regarded as the most important harpist in modern jazz today.

the new generations of women in jazz are part of a scene that has largely abandoned male dominance.

This brief historical outline has only been able to show a few musical positions. Interestingly, all of them were Afro-American. In the USA, jazz was still considered a dirty child for a long time, who had just been avoided by »white« Americans. That was only to really change with fusion and smooth-jazz at the end of the 1970s. As is well known, things looked different in Europe. Here, musicians like Irène Schweizer, who had shaped the up-and-coming Free Jazz movement on piano (and drums as well) since the early 1960s, Joëlle Léandre on double bass and Maggie Nichols as a vocalist could take on leading roles. Above all as members of the Feminist Improvising Group, which was formed in the late 1970s, feminist criticism of patriarchal structures in general and jazz in particular could be associated with musical-cultural expression.

But what does it look like today, must be asked at this point. Especially from the current jazz hub London come many female musicians who have caused a sensation lately. Be it the tenor saxophonist Nubya Garcia, the trumpeter and Kokoroko bandleader Sheila Maurice-Grey, the guitarist Shirley Tetteh (all three are also members of Nèrija) or the trumpeter and flugelhorn player Yazz Ahmed; all are united by the fact that they not only perform as outstanding musicians and instrumentalists, but also contribute their intercultural, migrant identity to jazz playing in addition to their female position. Afro-Atlantic, Arabic or Nigerian AND female – both are represented with pride. They are, as it were, children of an (East) London scene that has largely abandoned male dominance.

But a lot is also happening on the European continent: the two Austrians Muriel Grossmann and Katharina Ernst are only two of the artists who have to be named. While Grossmann as a tenor saxophonist in be-bop and hard-bop of a John Coltrane has already caused quite an echo, Ernst as a solo drummer stands for an unacademic avant-garde sound that skilfully combines electroacoustic influences and jazz. Of course, this cannot be more than a small insight into the history of jazz from a »female perspective«, but on closer inspection a number of structural obstacles can be identified and named which have ensured and continue to ensure that female jazz musicians (above all instrumentalists) neither possess the (supposed) impact nor are able to live from monetary means to the same extent as their male colleagues. Accordingly, the demands of the Union Deutscher Jazzmusiker (UDJ) can only be interpreted as minimum demands; this does little for the »mothers« of jazz today. An occupation with their work, however, should be a must for every jazz listener.


You can find the Vinyl records of Women In Jazz in our HHV Records webshop

Your Comment
1 Comments
24.09.2019 17:19
93.dkel:
It would be interesting to hear an explination of "2% of instrumentalists, but 86% of singers are female" though.. I think these kinds of facts are really important to the 'debate' as they indicate a sway of the stats the other way in other areas.

I get that this is also hinting at the commercial side of the business and attitudes towards women in the business world but still the main things stated here at the start were about the number of musicians that were female. I think those two things are different things and one may just be a more natural difference.
― answer
Related Articles
Music Essay | posted 24.06.2019
British Jazz
On The Hot Spot
Jazz in Great Britain is in the midst of a generational shift. New talents from Manchester to London are revising gridlocked listening habits and are testing the limits of the genre. But why now?
Music List | posted 03.07.2019
Polish Jazz
An introduction in 10 vinyl records
The Polish jazz scene is considered one of the most important and creative in Europe. Today it oscillates between superficial conventions and hidden ruptures. A little search for clues.
Music Interview | posted 16.06.2020
Gary Bartz
»We no longer see reality«
The Grammy-winning soprano saxophonist shared the stage with Miles Davis, Art Blakey and Max Roach. Now he has recorded an album with British outfit Maisha — and discovered something new.
Music Portrait | posted 14.05.2020
Muriel Grossmann
Abstraction with a sea view
Saxophonist Muriel Grossmann reaches abstraction on the Balearic Islands, rides the waves with hard bop and even amazes billionaires with standards. Who is the secret pioneer of the spiritual revival?
Music Portrait | posted 07.07.2020
International Anthem
In search of the truth
For six years the label International Anthem from Chicago has been reliably delivering jazz with their own attitude and idea. Although the founders refuse to be ascribed almost any kind of attribution to a genre. For them, the most beautiful sound is just always: the truth.
Music Portrait | posted 30.06.2020
We Jazz
With emphasis on We
We Jazz, that stands for edgy, surprising jazz from the north. And also not. Since 2013 the festival has been held in Helsinki, since 2016 the label was founded. Matti Nives mainly publishes Finnish bands there. And acts as one of the most important networkers of the local scene.
Music Essay | posted 09.07.2020
Baltic & Finnish Jazz
Removing Boundaries
While jazz from London to L.A. is evolving a fresh pop sensibility or even tries to update the fusion heritage, cool flavors between new blood and nostalgia are cultivated on the shores of the Baltic Sea. Here the genre is cosmopolitan as well and yet totally distinct.
Music Essay | posted 19.11.2012
Tools Of War
Respect Where It All Began
Born in the mid-90s, Tools Of War is a small frontier fighting to bridge this gap between a legendary past and the mainstream present.
Music Essay | posted 06.10.2020
A Journey Into Turkish Music
Anadolu Pop
Altın Gün, Derya Yıldırım & Grup Şimşek or Gaye Su Akyol: more and more bands are again referring to the sound of Anadolu Pop, which was formed in Turkey in the 1960s. But is it a revival? We clarify.
Music Essay | posted 07.10.2020
A Journey Into Turkish Music
Gastarbeiter*innen Musik
Simultaneously with the genesis of Anadolu Pop, a viral infrastructure is developing in West Germany. This »guest worker music« has always only touched the public consciousness. The economic exchange could have also been a cultural one.
Music Review | posted 16.06.2015
Aidan Baker & Idklang
In The Red Room
In Idklang, Aidan Baker has found a partner who provides an informal frame to his exuberant arts.
Music Review | posted 10.06.2015
Jamie xx
In Colours
On his debut, Jamie xx hat got it all right. It’s an incredibly exquisite record – exquisite enough to be disgusted.
Music Review | posted 15.06.2015
HELM
Olympic Mess
Overcoming stress through music: On »Olympic Mess«, Luke Younger aka HELM is trying to handle his very own chaos.
Music Review | posted 08.06.2015
Ben Zimmermann
The Baltika Years
The musical opportunities deriving from an old operating system have hardly ever been explored – Ben Zimmerman has dedicated ten years to this endeavor.
Music Review | posted 19.06.2015
Ken Camden
Dream Memory
On »Dream Memory«, Ken Camden is trying to close the sound gap between guitar strings and synthesizers.
Music Interview | posted 18.04.2011
Knxwledge
Beats and Soul as a Mind Set
The beat scene knows a broad variety of names, producers and people who are pushing the game to the next level constantly. One of the names you should definitely be familiar with is Knxwledge.
Music Review | posted 09.06.2015
Jenny Hval
Apocalypse, girl
Hval doesn’t nag and moan – she asks questions. You’ll find the answers by following her into the unpleasent. In the end, you’ll know what’s to go down.
Music Interview | posted 02.07.2011
Gold Panda
Just to make it better
Last year’s Lucky Shiner was one of the records, where the Beat-enthusiasts, the Caribou-listener and the electronic nerd come together sharing the headphones. Valentin Menedetter met Gold Panda for an interview and explains the basics.
Music Review | posted 08.06.2015
Container
LP
Crackpot-polyrhythmics, hickup-groove, hip hop from hell: Container doesn’t give a damn. His third record, »LP«, is racy, frenetic and awesome.
Music Review | posted 17.07.2012
TNGHT
TNGHT
Trance and 8-Bit meets Traprap-Instrumentals and Crunk. Hide yo kids, hide yo wife; TNGHT are tearing everything down.
Music Interview | posted 14.11.2011
fLako
»I like the idea of reincarnation«
Latest with his last album, The Mesektet, fLako makes clear that he will not stand still artistically. Instead he is reinventing itself again and again. His recently released EP Carving Away The Clay is a further testimony of becoming.
Music Review | posted 26.09.2014
Hudson Mohawke
Chimes EP
Those asking for Hudson Mohawke will get Hudson Mohawke. However, those waiting for HudMo, the inventor, will be disappointed.
Music Interview | posted 03.07.2011
Dustin O'Halloran
»I really love to sculpt the notes«
The pianist and film composer Dustin O’Halloran just released Lumiere, a soundtrack without a film. We’ve talked to him about the power of the piano, the magic of improvisation and his colleague Hauschka.
Music Interview | posted 12.05.2014
Jaakko Eino Kalevi
About Love And Other Mental Illnesses
Jaakko Eino Kalevi looks like a stoned angel in a woolie, works as a tram driver and with »No End« he released on of the best songs of 2013. About time we get to know him. A conversation about love, music and how to wash laundry.
Art Interview | posted 13.06.2013
Eliot Lee Hazel
The Stranger
Eliot Lee Hazel’s photographs of musicians are often gritty, raw, filled with cinematic language. British Hazel lives in America, is only 21 years-old and yet he’s already photographed Yeasayer, Thom Yorke, Ariel Pink and Cat Power.
Music List
Crumb
10 All Time Favs
Since their debut »Jinx« in 2019, Crumb have been considered the next big thing in music . Now their new album »Ice Melt« is out. The perfect opportunity to ask them about 10 records that have shaped, improved and educated them.
Music Interview
Adrian Younge
Sonic history lesson
»The American Negro« marks the beginning of a new chapter in Adrian Younge’s work. It is more frontal, more politically charged, and more self-assured. He wants to teach. We had the opportunity for an in-depth interview.
Music List
Leon Vynehall
10 All Time Favs
With his new album »Rare, Forever«, British producer Leon Vynehall continues the path he started with »Nothing Is Still« 3 years ago. Today he tells us 10 vinyl records that have shaped, improved and educated him.
Music Column
Records Revisited
Gil Scott-Heron – Pieces Of A Man (1971)
He was called the “Godfather of Hip Hop” because he wrote about drugs, racism and the Divided States of America. Gil Scott-Heron’s most successful album is now 50 years old – and more timely than ever.
Music List
Jenn Wasner (Flock Of Dimes)
10 All Time Favs
With her solo project Flock of Dimes, Jenn Wasner has just released her most personal and at the same time most substantially far-reaching album. We asked the musician to name 10 Vinyl records that have shaped, improved, and educated her.
Music Portrait
Gondwana Records
Soul And Character
As a DJ and musician, Matthew Halsall became a label operator. Starting with a local focus on Manchester’s contemporary jazz scene, the trumpeter, composer and bandleader has since given his imprint Gondwana Records a fairly international focus.
Music Column
Records Revisited
Yellow Magic Orchestra – BGM (1981)
Cues for the future: on their fourth album, »BGM«, the synth wizards of Yellow Magic Orchestra drafted background music for generations to come.
Music Portrait
Important Records
Deep Listening Forever!
Whehter it’s Pauline Oliveros, Éliane Radigue, Alina Kalancea or Caterina Barbieri: For 20 years now, Important Records has been like a well-stocked record shop for exciting sounds and music that needs to be heard intensely.
Art Portrait
Vincent de Boer
Like Jazz With Brushes
Dutch artist Vincent de Boer has become a regular band member of the British jazz band Ill Considered. He draws record covers based on the grooves he hears. For »The Stroke«, the process has now been reversed.
Music Portrait
Far Out Recordings
At the epicenter of the Brazil craze
Joe Davis is the train driver whose bandwagon a whole generation of Brazil-affine producers jumped on in the mid-nineties. With his Far Out Recordings label, he became the worldwide representative of Brazilian music culture.
Music List
Aaron Frazer
10 All Time Favs
»Introducing« is the name of Aaron Frazer’s first solo album. As the drummer of Durand Jones & The Indications, however, he is by no means an unknown name. So musically it’s off to the sixties. He tells us what actually influenced him musically.
Music Portrait
On The Corner
Bangers for the backroom
With his label On the Corner Records, Pete Buckenham serves a heady stew of afro-futuristic jazz concepts and contemporary street grooves beyond the genre ascriptions, and is opening the gates to the sound universe of tomorrow.
Music Portrait
Tidal Waves
Riding the Wave
A powerful wave has already washed many treasures ashore. Seen in this way, the name fits, because the Belgian reissue label Tidal Waves searches for, discovers and publishes pearls of music history believed to be lost.
Music Portrait
Mort Garson
Music for plants and people
He was involved in over 900 songs and reached number 1 on the Billboard charts, but Mort Garson’s current fame is based on an encounter with Bob Moog, whom he persuaded to give him one of his synthesizers. A rediscovery.
Music Portrait
Dark Entries
Between Disco, Goth and Porno Soundtracks
Since 2009, Josh Cheon has been running his label for underground music from the 1980s and those who want to be the next big underground hit. Next year he will have released over 300 records. We introduce you to the label from San Francisco.
Music Interview
Makaya McCraven
»I'm excavating sounds«
Makaya McCraven is one of the most leading jazz musicians of these days. Not only his hometown Chicago, but the whole world seems to be inspired by the free approach to the jazz heritage in his music. We had the chance for an interview.
Music List
Record Store Day 2020 – 3rd Drop
12 releases you should look out for
On October 24, 2020 the third of three Record Store Days will take place this year. More than 120 exclusive releases have been announced. We have picked out twelve records that we would like to recommend to you.
Music Essay
A Journey Into Turkish Music
Gastarbeiter*innen Musik
Simultaneously with the genesis of Anadolu Pop, a viral infrastructure is developing in West Germany. This »guest worker music« has always only touched the public consciousness. The economic exchange could have also been a cultural one.
Music Essay
A Journey Into Turkish Music
Anadolu Pop
Altın Gün, Derya Yıldırım & Grup Şimşek or Gaye Su Akyol: more and more bands are again referring to the sound of Anadolu Pop, which was formed in Turkey in the 1960s. But is it a revival? We clarify.
Music List
Record Store Day 2020 – 2nd Drop
Another 12 releases you should look out for
On September 26, 2020 the second of three Record Store Days this year will take place. More than 150 exclusive releases have been announced. We have picked out twelve vinyl records that we would like to recommend to you.
Music Portrait
Melody As Truth
On the threshold of sound and silence
With his label Melody As Truth, Jonny Nash moves between balearic and ambient. The journey leads from new age to a new art of world chamber music.
Music Interview
Kelly Lee Owens
»We store emotions in our body«
The Welsh musician released her second album »Inner Song« which wipes tears from cried-out eyes with one hand after the closing set while opening the window into everyday life with the other. A conversation with Owens about rave memories, trauma sessions and her challenge with Four Tet.
Music List
Harmonious Thelonious
10 All Time Favs
With »Plong« Stefan Schwander shakes the foundations of club music. His new solo album as Harmonious Thelonious lets everyday noises develop an eerie life of their own. He told us which 10 records have have shaped, improved and formed him.
Music List
Record Store Day 2020 – 1st Drop
12 vinyl records to look out for
On August 29, 2020 the first of three Record Store Days will take place this year. More than 350 exclusive releases have been announced for this event alone. We have picked out twelve records that we would like to recommend to you.
Music List
Jonathan Bree
10 All Time Favs
Jonathan Bree hides his face behind a latex mask. Well, right. But that’s not the most remarkable thing about the new zealander. Because he is first and foremost a first-rate songwriter. He told us which 10 records have shaped, improved and formed him.
Music Portrait
Light In The Attic
Everything Is Illuminated
For almost 20 years, the Seattle-based record label Light In The Attic has been shedding light on those releases that have been in the dark. The fact that they focused on vinyl right from the start, today the label is considered a pioneer.
Music List
Jay Glass Dubs
10 All Time Favs
»Soma« means »body« in Greek and that’s who the music of Jay Glass Dubs is aimed at. »Soma« is also the name of his new album. This was the chance to ask the Greek musician for 10 Vinyl records that formed him. He answers in, well, Greek.
Music Portrait
WeWantSounds
Contagious passion
WeWantSounds has been publishing music from the 1970s and 1980s since 2015. The name of the label is a catchphrase. When the Parisian two-man company selects the reissues, genre and country borders don‘t matter.
Music Essay
Baltic & Finnish Jazz
Removing Boundaries
While jazz from London to L.A. is evolving a fresh pop sensibility or even tries to update the fusion heritage, cool flavors between new blood and nostalgia are cultivated on the shores of the Baltic Sea. Here the genre is cosmopolitan as well and yet totally distinct.
Music Portrait
International Anthem
In search of the truth
For six years the label International Anthem from Chicago has been reliably delivering jazz with their own attitude and idea. Although the founders refuse to be ascribed almost any kind of attribution to a genre. For them, the most beautiful sound is just always: the truth.
Music Portrait
We Jazz
With emphasis on We
We Jazz, that stands for edgy, surprising jazz from the north. And also not. Since 2013 the festival has been held in Helsinki, since 2016 the label was founded. Matti Nives mainly publishes Finnish bands there. And acts as one of the most important networkers of the local scene.
Music Portrait
Roy Ayers
Warm vibrations with universal attraction
The American vibraphonist, singer, songwriter and arranger Roy Ayers is one of the most sampled contemporary musicians. With songs like »Everybody Loves The Sunshine«, the soul jazz legend, which celebrates it’s 80th birthday in September, became the main inspiration for Acid Jazz in the late 90s. His new album “Roy Ayers JID 002” on Jazz Is Dead with Adrian Younge and ex-ATCQ producer Ali Shaheed Muhammad continues his golden period of the Polydor years in the 70s seamlessly.
Music Interview
Gary Bartz
»We no longer see reality«
The Grammy-winning soprano saxophonist shared the stage with Miles Davis, Art Blakey and Max Roach. Now he has recorded an album with British outfit Maisha — and discovered something new.
Music Portrait
Dekmantel
Infinite Holidays
For the better part of a decade now, the Dekmantel imprint from Amsterdam is successfully squaring the circle as label, festival and promoter of several events: Connecting innovation and underground with a quality standard that is by now globally recognized without failing its aspirations. An end? Even in times of crisis far away.
Music List
Rafael Anton Irisarri
10 All Time Favs
Ambient? Maybe. But with splinters of metal, neo-classical and other stuff. Rafael Anton Irisarri paints overwhelming sound paintings with thick brushstrokes. For us the American composer has revealed his influences.
Music Portrait
Muriel Grossmann
Abstraction with a sea view
Saxophonist Muriel Grossmann reaches abstraction on the Balearic Islands, rides the waves with hard bop and even amazes billionaires with standards. Who is the secret pioneer of the spiritual revival?
Music Portrait
Roza Terenzi
Rave in a time capsule
Roza Terenzi turns past rave days upside down and brushes it with jungle breaks and techno cuts. On »Modern Bliss« she finally ends up in the future.
Music Portrait
Soviet Grail
Collective memory
Amid jazz experiments, electronic brutalism and psychedelic underground, Sergey Klimov digs for treasures for which musicians ended up in prison. With Soviet Grail, the Russian label boss traces the history of Soviet music.
Music List
ADULT.
10 All Time Favs
ADULT. have been making music for more than 20 years now. And they still don’t want simple attributions, sunlight, self-deception. Instead they wanted to call us records, which they shaped, improved, formed.
Music Interview
Quelle Chris
Accepting the chaos
He’s the most prolific oddball of the rap underground. And he’s on fire. With »Innocent Country 2« Quelle Chris follows up on his groundbreaking record »Guns« and a process where hopelessness is contradicted by accepting a surreal anxiety.
Music List
Peaking Lights
10 All Time Favs
In these days the new album «E S C A P E» of the Peaking Lights is released on Dekmantel. We had the opportunity to ask Aaron Coyes and Indra Dunis about 10 records that they have shaped, improved and formed.